25 Best Aftershaves for Men in 2024

Looking for the best aftershave for men in 2024? Check out our top 25 picks for ultimate post-shave comfort and skin care.

When it comes to grooming, a daily shave is a staple for most men. But aftershave is not, and it really should be. Not only does it provide relief after a shave, but it also helps to soothe irritated skin and leave a refreshing scent in its wake. With consistent use, it can even make the shaving process smoother.

To make your decision easier, we've scoured the market to bring you the 25 best aftershaves for men in 2024. From options for sensitive skin to rejuvenating moisturizers, we have something for everyone. We hope you'll have found the aftershave for you by the end of this list.

1. Blu Atlas Aftershave

Say goodbye to the harshness and irritation of traditional aftershave! Blu Atlas has formulated this healing, soothing aftershave specifically to combat redness, itching, and general post-shave discomfort.

Blu Atlas have chosen naturally hydrating ingredients like shea butter and aloe vera leaf juice that keep your skin feeling soft while protecting its delicate moisture barrier. Rose flower water is also included, known for its anti-inflammatory properties to help heal scars, burns, or cuts. This aftershave might just be the answer you were looking for!

2. Noble Otter - Two Kings Aftershave

If you want to take your post-shave skincare routine to the next level, then Noble Otter's Two Kings Aftershave Splash is a good choice. This alcohol-based aftershave contains natural astringent witch hazel and plant extracts like provitamin B5 which nourish and soothe the skin while providing relief from irritation.

The sophisticated blend of blackcurrant top notes, jasmine, lily, rose, and carnation heart notes, and oud, sandalwood, and oakmoss base notes make this aftershave a winner in both scent and performance. The light formula absorbs quickly into the skin and doesn't clog pores or leave behind a greasy residue – just smooth refreshment and a healthy shine that will have you feeling confident and looking your best.

3. Proraso - After Shave for Men

Proraso After Shave for Men is the perfect product to provide immediate relief from razor burns after shaving. The creamy texture goes on soft and absorbs quickly into your skin, calming inflammation - particularly around the cheeks. Plus, you don't need to use a lot of this product; just a little bit goes a very long way!

Not only does it have excellent moisturizing capabilities, but Proraso also has an irresistible masculine, woody scent that isn't overpowering. Plus, it's made with 97% natural ingredients, so you can be sure you're getting the best quality product without any parabens, silicones, or mineral oils in sight. Unlike some other balms out there, it won't leave a shiny residue - just soft and supple skin.

4. Nivea Men - Sensitive Post Shave Balm

Are you dealing with redness, itchiness, tightness, or burning after shaving? Nivea Men Sensitive Post-Shave Balm can help! This special formula is designed to soothe and nourish your skin – giving you relief from post-shave irritations.

Natural ingredients like vitamin E, chamomile, and witch hazel extracts form a protective barrier against environmental aggressors, leaving your skin feeling smooth and comfortable for the whole day. And its alcohol-free formula means it's suitable for daily use without any worries about damaging your skin further.

Find out how this healing balm can make all the difference in your grooming routine today!

5. Harry's - Post-Shave Balm With Aloe

Want to feel refreshed and soothed after you shave? Harry's Post-Shave Balm is the ideal solution! Natural aloe vera and cucumber extract work together to cool, moisturize, and balance your skin. Best of all – it dries quickly, so there's no worry about it leaving you looking or feeling greasy. Plus, its pH balancing formula is paraben-free, sulfate-free, and never tested on animals. Your face can look and feel great every time you use it!

6. Jack Black - Post Shave Cooling Gel

Maybe you are looking for an aftershave that's simple yet sophisticated? A product that does exactly what it says on the tin without any added irritants? Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel is your perfect post-shaving solution.

This powerful formula contains natural ingredients, such as chamomile, aloe leaf juice, and balm mint, to soothe redness and irritation while hydrating skin. Chamomile also helps protect against environmental damage and aging signs, while the aloe leaf juice and balm mint provide a cool sensation to refresh the skin. Plus, this scientifically backed gel is super light and won't clog the pores. It has a pleasant aroma from the combination of botanicals like sage, lavender, and rosemary, making it incredibly versatile – you can still wear your favorite cologne.

So, if you're looking for a simple but effective aftershave that won't let you down – Jack Black Post Shave Cooling Gel is your go-to solution. Providing a boost to help revive tired skin in the morning or soothe sunburns, apply a small amount to your face and neck after shaving and enjoy the refreshing effects!

7. Kiehl's - Facial Fuel Aftershave

Kiehl's Facial Fuel is an amazing choice if you're looking for a gentle, effective aftershave. Not only does it provide an invigorating scent, but its lightweight formula also provides intense hydration and nourishment to help dry or sensitive skin types stay moisturized all day long.

Plus, with natural ingredients like vitamin C and caffeine, this aftershave can even help reduce signs of fatigue.

There's no residue that some skin care products leave behind either; Kiehl's Facial Fuel absorbs quickly so your skin looks and feels refreshed without being weighed down by oiliness.

8. Gentleman Jon - Alum Block

Are you ready to upgrade your shave game? Look no further than Gentleman Jon's Alum Block aftershave!

This soap-like bar is made of 100% potassium alum, a material that is naturally astringent and has antiseptic properties. That helps prevent annoying bumps, cuts, and nicks. Plus, it tones your skin while closing pores. And the best part? If it's stored properly, then your Gentleman Jon's Alum Block will last a lifetime. So why not give it a try today?

Knock out your shave routine without fear with Gentleman Jon's Alum Block.

9. Fieldworks - Face of Danger After Shave Elixir

The Face of Danger After Shave Elixir is a unique all-natural aftershave powered by the best organic ingredients. It won't let you down, offering effective pore closure and skin nourishment – delivered in an earthy natural scent that's not too strong.

With every use, witch hazel and aloe vera work together to ensure your pores are clear and inflammation reduced, while bentonite clay pulls out toxins from your skin and locks in essential moisture.

Fieldworks have designed this product with travelers in mind – it comes in a convenient size that meets TSA regulations. Plus, since it's made in the United States using small batch processes, it's easy on the environment too!

10. Murdock London - Post Shave Balm

Are you looking for the perfect aftershave? Look no further than Murdock London's Post Shave Balm. This decadent balm is inspired by Victorian London and is made with only the finest quality ingredients. It has zero parabens, sulfates, or phthalates, so it won't irritate or dry your skin.

The quenching, moisturizing combination of witch hazel extract, mallow extract, and sweet almond oil will leave your skin feeling soft, smooth, and comfortable. Mallow extract reduces redness and inflammation on sensitive skin, while sweet almond oil restores luster.

With just a small amount of this aftershave, you'll immediately notice the difference in your skin - it will be softer than ever, and your open pores will be sealed.

11. Baxter of California - Shave Tonic

Baxter of California's Shave Tonic is here to help you get the smoothest shave possible while caring for your skin before and after.

Cool any razor burn with a blend of menthol and essential oils like rosemary, eucalyptus, camphor, and spearmint. Get an extra dose of nourishment from vitamins E, D, and A; hydration from aloe vera; plus soothing pH balance for your skin – all without parabens. Enjoy the best shave possible!

12. Caswell-Massey - Number Six After Shave

Immerse yourself in history with Caswell-Massey Number Six After Shave. This is an iconic American product that George Washington himself used back in 1780. The original recipe from 1772 has been perfected with a balance of 27 different aromatics, such as orange blossom, rosemary, and bergamot scents. These ingredients give off a lingering aroma throughout the day, ensuring you stay smelling great at all times.

The luxurious Caswell-Massey packaging will make anyone feel special and reminds us just how far this brand has come since its beginnings over 266 years ago. The "Golden Cap" edition is especially eye-catching and adds to the high-quality experience that this aftershave provides.

13. The Art of Shaving - Aftershave Balm

The Art of Shaving know something special about aftershave. Their aftershave balm is infused with lavender essential oils for a unique and soothing experience.

Unlike some other products, it absorbs quickly and provides long-lasting moisture all day, so your skin stays soft and hydrated. And if lavender doesn't sound like you, check out their wide selection of scents from sandalwood to bergamot.

The Art of Shaving know that feeling great starts with looking great. That's why they develop high-quality shaving creams and aftershaves to help bring the barbershop feel right into your home.

14. Fulton & Roark - Aftershave Cloths

Are you looking for a way to soothe razor burn and improve your complexion? Fulton & Roark Aftershave Cloths may be just the thing for you.

Combining natural astringent witch hazel with essential oils like tea tree and eucalyptus, these pocket-sized cloths pack some serious punch. Plus, the special formula includes bergamot for a refreshing citrusy, spicy scent that is free of bergapten, a naturally occurring compound that can cause increased sensitivity to sunlight. They also make sure to include sagebrush – a native North American plant – for its anti-inflammatory and anti-fungal properties.

With all of this goodness in one tiny package, your skin will be clean, refreshed, and razor burn free in no time!

15. Brickell - Instant Relief Aftershave

Brickell's natural, alcohol-free men's aftershave lotion is made with the best ingredients to keep your skin looking healthy and feeling smooth. Soothe post-shave irritation, prevent razor bumps, and alleviate redness with this fast-absorbing formula that won't leave any stickiness or clog pores.

Their powerful blend of aloe vera, hyaluronic acid, coconut, and other natural ingredients provides a calming, hydrating layer of protection for your face and neck. Restore balance to your skin and make post-shave discomfort a thing of the past with this lightweight men's aftershave lotion — perfect for all skin types!

16. L'Occitane - Cade After Shave Balm

You deserve a post-shave experience that's luxurious, soothing, and protective, and L'Occitane Cade After Shave Balm provides it in abundance.

Enriched with cade wood essential oil, this balm reduces irritation, tightness, and feelings of discomfort after shaving. It also contains a purifying complex composed of shea butter and rosemary essential oils to help protect your skin from moisture loss. Just dab the velvety balm on after shaving for supple, moisturized skin that stays feeling great all day long. In addition, you have the added bonus of a slight woody scent from the cade wood essential oil.

With 100% satisfaction, you can feel confident that L'Occitane Cade After Shave Balm is a superior post-shave choice.

17. Aesop - Moroccan Neroli Post-Shave Lotion

For the man who takes pride in the care of his skin, Aesop Moroccan Neroli Post-Shave Lotion is another great choice on our list of the best aftershaves for men.

This luxurious paraben- and cruelty-free aftershave will have you looking your best. Its warm, woody, and spicy scent is perfect for the modern man, while its lightweight texture quickly soaks into your skin to leave it calm and hydrated. All you need is half a teaspoon of this lotion to get the job done – meaning this product will last you a long time.

Perfect for normal, combination, or sensitive skin types, apply it either morning or evening, depending on when you prefer to shave. Experience why premier costs come with premier products when you invest in the Aesop Moroccan Neroli Post-Shave Lotion.

18. Truefitt & Hill - Ultimate Comfort Aftershave Balm

Experience the ultimate comfort of Truefitt & Hill Aftershave Balm. This luxurious moisturizer is packed with soothing lanolin and aloe vera extract, making it perfect for those with temperamental skin. Its unscented formula helps reduce irritation while being suitable for all skin types – but specially designed to pamper gentlemen's sensitive skin.

19. Bevel - Shave Restoring Balm

Experience the difference with Bevel Shave Restoring Balm!

This aftershave was designed to cool and soothe your skin without the sting while still giving you all of the benefits associated with a quality aftershave. Tea tree oil replaces alcohol to help decrease razor bumps and ingrown hairs, while shea butter and jojoba oil deeply nourish and hydrate. The addition of lactic acid and salicylic acid assist in exfoliating and toning the skin.

On top of that, the product is formulated without any parabens, sulfates, dyes, silicones, or other artificial ingredients – so it's safe for use even on sensitive skin.

20. Terre d’Hermès - Aftershave Balm

Terre d'Hermes nourishing aftershave balm is here to provide your skin with all the hydration and comfort that it needs. With its light, fluid formula, it's easy to apply and absorbs quickly, helping to soothe razor burn. Enjoy feeling your skin being nourished, all without any greasiness.

Wear the beautiful scent of Terre d'Hermes with pride, thanks to this amazing balm.

21. Cella - Organic Aftershave Lotion

Perfect for giving your skin a gentle, refreshing boost and keeping it moisturized after your shave, Cella's special formula in their aftershave lotion is enriched with organic aloe vera to soothe reddening, prevent irritation, and leave your skin feeling hydrated.

Their exclusive fragrance starts out with a blend of fruity notes combined with an aromatic hint of pink pepper. The heart has an elegant mix of Damask rose and jasmine surrounded by smoky birch. To finish off, labdanum, precious woods, amber, and musk add incredible warmth and long-lasting scent.

22. Clinique for Men - Post-Shave Soother

Experience the soothing power of aloe with this special formula. Clinique's unique blend helps to reduce intense redness and itchy irritation caused by razor burn while providing much-needed hydration for dry skin. Enjoy the refreshingly cooling sensation of aloe vera when you use it – the perfect feeling after a shave!

23. Marie Veronique - Aftershave Tonic

Say goodbye to post-shave irritation with the Marie Veronique Aftershave Tonic.

This luxuriously light tonic is formulated with green tea and black willow bark extract, elderberry extract, apple cider vinegar, cucumber, tea tree oil, and trace minerals – all carefully chosen to restore your skin's microbiome and balance pH levels. And that's not all, the formula is also scented naturally with essential oils rather than synthetic fragrances. To top it off, this aftershave tonic is suitable for any skin type.

Simply shake the bottle and apply a bit of the product onto a cotton pad before wiping it over your face and neck (avoiding eyes), then enjoy smooth skin without any burning or other discomfort. Make the Marie Veronique Aftershave Tonic a part of your daily skincare routine and stay fresh - even on your toughest days.

24. Fellow - Everyday Tonic

Fellow Everyday Tonic brings something slightly different to the table. This all-in-one skin and hair care product is designed to lift dirt, remove grease, tighten pores, promote healing, and smell great!

Included here is a powerful blend of natural botanicals in an astringent base – witch hazel, aloe vera, bisabolol, and eucalyptus all come together to soothe and purify your skin or hair. Lemon extract helps with pesky ingrown hairs, while arnica provides natural pain relief as well as reduces swelling. Vitamins A, C & E nourish both your skin and hair for added benefit. Plus, it smells amazing - fresh herbal notes of bergamot, frankincense, eucalyptus, and cedarwood are a wonderful combination.

This product is alcohol-, paraben-, and sulfate-free and is made with 100% natural fragrance. And of course, it's never tested on animals or made anywhere but in the US!

25. Aqua Velva - Sensitive 5-in-1 After Shave Balm

Introducing Aqua Velva Sensitive 5-in-1 After Shave Balm. This aftershave balm will be your go-to for all of your post-shave needs in one simple product. It's non-burning and provides all-day moisture, helping soothe unwanted redness and irritation, preventing bumps, and fighting ingrown hairs. What's more, it has a light and refreshing scent that helps lock in moisture.

It won't leave behind a greasy film and is ideal to also use as a facial moisturizer!

In conclusion, a good aftershave is a huge boon to any man's grooming routine. Not only does it provide relief from the dreaded razor burn, but it can also boost your confidence with a pleasant scent. From our list of the best men’s aftershaves, you can find the perfect option for your skin type and scent preferences. Whether you prefer a classic brand or a newer release, these top choices are guaranteed to give you a smooth and refreshing post-shave experience.

So, take your pick from our list and level up your grooming game in 2023. Be sure to keep reading to get just a little more information that can help you when you decide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What should I look for in an aftershave?

When selecting an aftershave, it's important to consider the ingredients so you can be sure that it will provide the relief and benefits that your skin needs. One of the very first things to look for is an astringent, like aloe vera or witch hazel, which soothes and calms irritated skin post-shave. These ingredients are especially good for those who have sensitive skin or if you experience razor burn frequently.

Next, consider opting for an aftershave that contains tea tree oil or other natural antiseptics, as these can help stop cuts from becoming infected and prevent ingrown hairs.

When choosing an aftershave, it's essential to select a product that is formulated with ingredients that nourish, hydrate, and soothe your skin, leaving you with a refreshing and pleasant experience.

What should I avoid in an aftershave?

Parabens, phthalates, and alcohol are commonly found in many skincare products, including aftershaves. However, it's recommended to avoid these ingredients as they can cause harmful consequences to your skin and body.

Firstly, studies have shown that parabens, frequently used as a preservative in cosmetics, have links to certain cancers and other health concerns. Secondly, phthalates can cause disruption to your endocrine system, which could lead to a variety of health issues. They are also widely used in the cosmetics industry. Sulfates are chemicals that act as drying agents and can dehydrate your skin. Lastly, alcohol, particularly high concentrations of alcohol, can be incredibly drying to and further irritate freshly shaved skin.

These ingredients can worsen existing conditions such as eczema and other skin irritation due to their stripping nature and should be avoided where possible.

What if I have sensitive skin?

If you have sensitive skin, then you should look for aftershaves that have ingredients intended to specifically soothe and calm irritation. Some ingredients you may want to consider:

Aloe Vera: Aloe vera is a widely known anti-inflammatory and can soothe any redness or irritation of the skin. Just think of what it does for sunburn, for example.

Chamomile: Chamomile is a flower that is known for its protective properties. It can absorb free radicals and reduce damage from environmental stressors. The scent is also quite calming.

Witch Hazel: Witch hazel is a naturally occurring astringent that can help reduce inflammation and redness in sensitive skin. It is frequently used as an alternative or in conjunction with aloe vera and can help support and strengthen the skin barrier.

Look for aftershaves that are free from alcohol and other harsh chemicals and instead have these types of gentle, soothing ingredients.

What are the qualities of a good aftershave?

When we shave, our pores open up, and if they are not sealed, dirt and bacteria can enter them, leading to skin irritation or breakouts. A good aftershave helps to close the pores to avoid these unwanted effects.

Another essential quality of a good aftershave is its ability to absorb quickly into the skin, leaving no residue. This can help prevent the clogging of pores, which can otherwise lead to breakouts or acne. When an aftershave absorbs into the skin rapidly, it provides instant relief and can calm any redness, restoring the skin's natural balance.

An aftershave that has both these qualities can offer several benefits for your skin post-shave. It minimizes the risk of inflammation while also providing instant relief from irritation and promoting healing.

Final Thoughts

Aftershave is not just a product for cosmetic purposes; it plays an important role in maintaining the health of your skin after shaving. When selecting an aftershave product, it is important to consider the ingredients it contains.

If you have sensitive skin, ingredients like aloe vera, chamomile, witch hazel, and vitamin E can help you avoid irritation, redness, and inflammation while repairing the damage. If you're looking for an aftershave that will help prevent infection and ingrown hairs, choose a product containing natural antiseptics like tea tree oil.

Avoid ingredients like parabens, phthalates, and high concentrations of alcohol. These can strip your skin of natural oils and cause irritation, dryness, and even serious health problems down the line.

In order to maintain healthy and happy skin after shaving, an aftershave with the right ingredients can go a long way. So, be sure that you choose a product that suits your skin and meets your requirements to have an enjoyable and refreshing aftershave experience.